Laine married Roger Rominger in 2015. In April 2022, the pair filed for legal separation with the court, and nine months later, they filed for dissolution of their marriage.
In an October 2023 podcast, Laine said that she "got rid of the last husband, who wanted to retire on a sailboat," citing she couldn't compromise due to her extreme seasickness.
She clarified that soon-to-be ex-husband Roger Rominger wasn't alone in attempting to foil her retirement plans. "My children have destroyed my dream," she joked on the podcast.
Laine explained, "So now I have five grandkids in Indianapolis that I didn't have when I bought the house," noting that she'll have to split her time between the two cities.